Ah...well that explains it then. In light of this, I would say that the mat being handed out randomly is the best way to handle that. The winners are already getting a much coveted card. Though I'd probably have gone with 1st and 2nd get a Wesker, then the player who scored the most decorations in the tourney (that isn't first or second) gets one and then a fellowship prize for most fun player to play with (again not one of the previous 3), i.e. the popularity prize.

