Originally Posted by Nejifan
"best' means capable of beating the most people. minus 4th/madara, guy has that award hands down barring jinchurriki.
guy is fast, off the charts fast. I'm sure physically, even with sharingan, itachi would struggle to keep up. and the gates don't take very long unless you go past the first few. it didn't take lee long against gaara to open the heal gate after using primary lotus. and he wasn't stationary either. as for projectiles, who says kakashi hasn't already tried that. He and guy go all out against each other (minus gates) I'm sure, otherwise they'd never know who was better.
perhaps though, 'wipe the floor' was a bit of an exageration.
you have absolutely no way of knowing that. we've seen a rock paper scissors match and guy suggesting other things <none of which were fighting>. for all we know, they haven't actually fought each other in years. itsa completely baseless statement. again, guy is hardcore but we have absolutely no idea how effective his sharingan counter is. all we can safely assume is that, with proper training, its better than looking at their eyes.
as for off the chartness...i wonder. and im not just saying that just to disagree with you. i kinda go back and forth. sometimes i think he's easily off the charts, other times i question it. currently im in a probably not mind set just because currently im thinking that the difference between stats <or at least some of them, like speed> becomes bigger the higher the stat is <aka, the difference between 4.5 and 5 being bigger than 0 and 0.5>. so as of right now im thinking that no one is off the charts in any stat unless they use some sort of power up <jinchuuriki, sage mode, gates, etc>
but of course neither of us can prove our beliefs as of right now.