hidan 1509

[sortofjosh]

does hidan's effect trigger if he's discarded dude to damage?

Also, would it trigger due to showdown damage?

[Laughing_Man]

Originally Posted by sortofjosh

does hidan's effect trigger if he's discarded dude to damage?

It would trigger but the effect would fail because he would not be in play.

Originally Posted by sortofjosh

Also, would it trigger due to showdown damage?

Yes.

[sortofjosh]

Originally Posted by Laughing_Man

It would trigger but the effect would fail because he would not be in play.

Follow Up Question:

Would four tails be ruled similarly in regards to his second effect? For instance, if a jutsu did one damage to him, would his effect fail?(considering that it is not valid)

[Laughing_Man]

Originally Posted by sortofjosh

Follow Up Question:

Would four tails be ruled similarly in regards to his second effect? For instance, if a jutsu did one damage to him, would his effect fail?(considering that it is not valid)

Yes, his effect would fail.