Does Bandai understand First round Byes?

[Shodaime]

VSA, I'm not confused about how it works. I asked Nick, he told me it doesn't work a certain way, and explained why.

Dalegna posted what he did in Q&A for different reasons. It's not because he didn't get what Nick said. And its not because we were trying to take advantage of anything. We initially thought the card worked one way, and then we were told it didn't. I'm fine with that.

MJM, I don't know of whatever reports you are talking about.

[Shino'sDad]

Originally Posted by Shodaime

Dalegna posted what he did in Q&A for different reasons. It's not because he didn't get what Nick said.

I'm sorry but I just find it hard to believe that. There is no other possible reason to ask that question in Q&A unless either

1) He doesn't believe me.
2) He wants to try to trick Justin into answering the question incorrectly
3) He doesn't get what I said.

1 and 3 are pretty much synonymous with each other. It's just hard for be to believe that the question didn't crop up Now of all times with This card because of some situation where being able to use his effect on Another opposed Ninja would have won someone the game, and thus they 'interpreted' the effect to hit any of your opponent's opposed Ninja on the Battlefield. There have been Countless cards that have stated "Target Opposing Ninja, All Opposing Ninja, 1 Opposing Ninja" etc and there was ample time for this sort of confusion to come up, but it didn't, because people Knew what opposing Ninja meant.

[Dalegna]

just so you kno i only asked because ppl asked me to ask anyway and it was to also get a better understanding of some of these wording it was no disrespect to you and if it makes you feel better we have been playing it with your ruling.


what VSA said makes lots of since to me

[Shino'sDad]

Originally Posted by Dalegna

just so you kno i only asked because ppl asked me to ask anyway and it was to also get a better understanding of some of these wording it was no disrespect to you and if it makes you feel better we have been playing it with your ruling.

It isn't that I feel disrespected at all, because I don't, it's more that I am disappointed in the situation because there are other cards that have used this exact wording before and no one, including yourself, every questioned it then. So I want to understand why it came up now other than the idea that someone could have won if it worked the other way and it became an issue because of that. If that were the case, it's as simple as referencing older cards like 4th Supremacy, and knowing that they don't work that way. =\

[Dalegna]

Originally Posted by Shino'sDad

It isn't that I feel disrespected at all, because I don't, it's more that I am disappointed in the situation because there are other cards that have used this exact wording before and no one, including yourself, every questioned it then. So I want to understand why it came up now other than the idea that someone could have won if it worked the other way and it became an issue because of that. If that were the case, it's as simple as referencing older cards like 4th Supremacy, and knowing that they don't work that way. =\

there where a few cards that said "opposing this Ninja" so that had me thinking some of these card dont say that why not? so i went out and looked up on what opposing really means and what i found almost notting maybe lack of searching skill on my behalf now i never found anything as clear as what VSA said so with the info that i found it lead me to believe Might guy could snipe and when SC told me blank didnt work because blank said so but i never knew why it didnt work nor did i get a explanation so i asked if your disappointed then so be it im not afraid to admit i was wrong.

[MJM]

I think he's more disappointed at the fact that you, a Judge who has proven, as far as Bandai records go, to be knowledgeable about the game, didn't know such a simple concept. Well, that's why I'm disappointed.

[OdionF.Baby]

Originally Posted by MJM

You act as if this is the first time we've gotten reports of NE players and judges, which includes those from MA, doing something like this. At this point, I am insulting you guys. From what was posted in the Q&A, I've come to the conclusion that Dalegna evolves into Spiritomb.

MJM who are you to insult anyone in this game? You've never done well at large event, you don't play the game, and your state has 1 good player and one tier 2 player. I dont care about bashing on MA players but YOU should not be the one doing it. Nick its obvious that the mass players(Not all)ask dumb questions and that our judge doesnt know the rulings but bringing it up over and over isnt going to change that.

[zbkillaz]

for the record i told them that it only works against battling against teams -.-.

It's really fun hearing people argue about rulings at the shop tho.

[WizKid]

Originally Posted by zbkillaz

for the record i told them that it only works against battling against teams -.-.

It's really fun hearing people argue about rulings at the shop tho.

I remember specifically that you agreed with us at first and then said , that wording is funny.

[Shino'sDad]

Originally Posted by WizKid

I remember specifically that you agreed with us at first and then said , that wording is funny.