Originally Posted by Nickuchiha
My only counter arguement to this one is that Kakashi is crying at the end of the chapter.
ah, you're right. I didn't notice that the first time I read it. I just saw that everything was getting rained on so I didn't catch it, but I just re-read that last page and you're right. hmm...
Originally Posted by TheLastHokage
"In the ninja world, those who break the rules are trash, that's true, but those who abandon their comrades are worse than trash."
(To Sasuke) "I won't allow my comrades to die. I'll protect you with my life. Trust me."
"I don't care if you are one of the legendary Sannin, the great shinobi of legend, I swear take one more step towards Sasuke and one of us will die here!"
This makes me think that Kakashi couldn't have killed Rin.
"This place makes me think about the mistakes I've made in the past… and I've made so many of them."
This is Fishy.
exactly. The only other theory I can think is that perhaps rin asked him to kill her for some reason, as per the 'dont let the opponents have your intel' thing? I can't see him making that choice of his own volition, so there is obviously some extenuating cir****tance.